57
decisions
with a cited verdict
17
real stores
sampled so far
14
research
sources cited
9
verified
quotes checked at source
Reel · from a graded decision

When product page add-to-cart works (and when it doesn't)

4 real stores from this decision, each with the note we recorded. Look first, then read the verdict.

View all reels
Today's verdict · decision №54

A sticky add-to-cart bar lifts mobile add-to-cart rates when product pages scroll past two screens, mobile sessions exceed 40%, and the product has a single clear call to action.

But it adds UI weight, potentially harming slow pages, confusing complex configurations, or causing layout shifts if not implemented cleanly.

Evidence · High40% of 5 sampled stores

Browse by stage

Storefront of the week

Real stores, walked one stop at a time.

4 real stops

When product page add-to-cart works (and when it doesn't)

4 real stops from the store examples and notes on this decision.

Allbirds — The product page features a prominent "SELECT A SIZE" button above the fold, which is the primary action to proceed with purchasing the item.
Strong

Allbirds

The product page features a prominent "SELECT A SIZE" button above the fold, which is the primary action to proceed with purchasing the item.

All stops
Read the full decision
Decisions in rotation

Questions teams are weighing

Each is a real question with a one-line verdict you can act on, and the proof behind it.

View all
The weekly digest

New decisions, once a week.

A short summary of the decisions and dataset changes we shipped that week — with the screenshots and cited sources. One click to unsubscribe.

Read past issues and subscribe on the weekly digest page.

Go to the weekly digest

Free · no paywalls · unsubscribe anytime